View Poll Results: I feel that the following above MSRP is fair and is what I am willing to pay:
NOTHING above MSRP



132
80.98%
No more than $100 above MSRP



4
2.45%
No more than $500 above MSRP



9
5.52%
No more than $1,000 above MSRP



9
5.52%
More than $1,000 above MSRP



1
0.61%
OTHER (Specify in reply below)



8
4.91%
Voters: 163. You may not vote on this poll
How much above MSRP is fair & reasonable? How much above MSRP are you willing to pay?
I don't know how the percentages are set up in this day and age, but I do have a pretty good idea how it was in the late '60s/early '70s (as I worked for a couple of GM dealerships for a while). Compacts were 12% of MSRP, mid size 14%, large (read Implala) 18%, the dealer also received a 1-2% rebate from GM once the car was sold. Now that has been a few years ago and I may be off a couple of percent here and there (the memory gets fuzzy on facts you have dragged up in years) and I'm sure that things have changed a great deal in the automotive industry since then, so I have no idea what the dealers take is today. Oh, and I will not pay a cent over MSRP, not even a couple of hundred dollars "processing fee" for them doing the paperwork that they are already required to do by law.
Clyde
Clyde
most dealer incentives were in the $700 range.
and there are no dealership "processing fee's" you talk of. there are taxes and DMV fees, but that's uncle sam reaching into your pocket, not the dealership.
Heres a link http://www.woodhouse.com/
No chevys, but they did it for my grand cherokee and a Dakota R/T they had left over.
They are the reason why ive never bought a new Camaro. Cheap bastards.
See what they are charging for challengers if you contact them.
No chevys, but they did it for my grand cherokee and a Dakota R/T they had left over.
They are the reason why ive never bought a new Camaro. Cheap bastards.
See what they are charging for challengers if you contact them.
**** this, I will NEVER NEVER PAY MSRP for ANY car.
Let alone anything over it, people who pay over the MSRP for a car are either dumb, retarted, stuipid, or just dont know any better.
IMO. Sorry if this is mean, but seriously, getting ripped off is not something I am "willing" to negotiate.
Stealerships make more money off crappy *** service, and selling extended warranties than most people will ever know. And dont even get me started on the "accessories", and other bull**** like "paint protection" that they try and weasel into every sell.
SO SCREW THEM, because thats what thier doing, screwing people, at least most of them are, and I will pay a little over invoice and nothing more. there is no way I will every pay a dealer a profit when they decieve, and snake oil sell all that other crap that they do.
I love all these people in here whining about how the dealership never makes money off an invoice car, BULL CRAP. They will always find someway of making money. ALWAYS.
Let alone anything over it, people who pay over the MSRP for a car are either dumb, retarted, stuipid, or just dont know any better.
IMO. Sorry if this is mean, but seriously, getting ripped off is not something I am "willing" to negotiate.
Stealerships make more money off crappy *** service, and selling extended warranties than most people will ever know. And dont even get me started on the "accessories", and other bull**** like "paint protection" that they try and weasel into every sell.
SO SCREW THEM, because thats what thier doing, screwing people, at least most of them are, and I will pay a little over invoice and nothing more. there is no way I will every pay a dealer a profit when they decieve, and snake oil sell all that other crap that they do.
I love all these people in here whining about how the dealership never makes money off an invoice car, BULL CRAP. They will always find someway of making money. ALWAYS.
And yes, the service and parts departments usually carry a dealership. Especially with the CRAP Chrysler was putting out back then, the service department was always busy.
But the service departments DON'T PAY THE SALESMAN'S COMMISIONS, CAR SALES DO. They have to eat too.Oh, and there was a $250 "pack" price that was the owners cut. It wasn't added on, it was just that they wouldn't go below $250 over invoice. The owner was going to get HIS even if everyone else in the deal got left out.
when i was working at honda, basically the fits were priced $600 over invoice, civics, elements, crv's and accords @ $1800 over invoice and s2000's, Odyssey's and Pilot's were ~$3600.
most dealer incentives were in the $700 range.
and there are no dealership "processing fee's" you talk of. there are taxes and DMV fees, but that's uncle sam reaching into your pocket, not the dealership.
most dealer incentives were in the $700 range.
and there are no dealership "processing fee's" you talk of. there are taxes and DMV fees, but that's uncle sam reaching into your pocket, not the dealership.
Clyde
$100 over INVOICE???? I would have HATED to be your salesman. NO offense, but don't you think the dealership is intitled to more than .3%???? NOT 3%, there's a decimal there. That's figured on a
$30,000 item. The salesman's commision on that would be what is called a "mini" which is either going to be NOTHING, or a whopping $25 bucks. (depending on the dealership's policy) Considering the average commission for the cars I sold (20 years ago) was around $300 per car average, YOU wouldn't be worth my time.
I think I understand why they try and screw you on the trade, because it is the only way they will make a buck off of you. I hate greedy dealers as much as the next guy, but $100 over cost on a $30,000 item is kind of ...........what's the word I'm looking for........cheap.
I think $2,000 profit to the dealer per transaction is a fair profit. Keep in mind out of that profit they have to pay the salesman the commission, the sales manager get's his cut, the finance manager get's his cut, the OWNER of the dealership get's his cut, and they have to pay lot taxes, utilities, rent/mortgage for the property and other operating costs. A $100 a car wouldn't allow any dealer to stay in business unless they were selling more than 1500 cars a month probably.
Would YOU work for a .3% profit?
$30,000 item. The salesman's commision on that would be what is called a "mini" which is either going to be NOTHING, or a whopping $25 bucks. (depending on the dealership's policy) Considering the average commission for the cars I sold (20 years ago) was around $300 per car average, YOU wouldn't be worth my time.
I think I understand why they try and screw you on the trade, because it is the only way they will make a buck off of you. I hate greedy dealers as much as the next guy, but $100 over cost on a $30,000 item is kind of ...........what's the word I'm looking for........cheap.
I think $2,000 profit to the dealer per transaction is a fair profit. Keep in mind out of that profit they have to pay the salesman the commission, the sales manager get's his cut, the finance manager get's his cut, the OWNER of the dealership get's his cut, and they have to pay lot taxes, utilities, rent/mortgage for the property and other operating costs. A $100 a car wouldn't allow any dealer to stay in business unless they were selling more than 1500 cars a month probably.
Would YOU work for a .3% profit?
I have always got my new cars under invoice. Just got a 2008 Toyota Yaris for $500 under invoice. Couldn't justify paying 50 a week for gas in my minivan when I can pay $25 to drive the same distance. Got my 2006 Caravan for a grand under sticker, my 99 Voyager 2 grand under, and my 95 Birdible 2 grand under. Shop around there will be dealer that will make you happy. My Toyota Dealer wants to sell me another car and he said I can get it for a grand under invoice since I just bought one. Still thinking about it but just lost my job after 19 years as it got outsourced to India.
To make a long story short:
1) I expect the dealers will try 3-5k ABOVE MSRP for the first 2-3 months.
2) I expect that after that short waiting period, not only will you be able to buy below MSRP, but I would bet deals in the invoice+$1000 will be common. I don't expect much below that unless there's end of year fac to dealer incentives on remaining models which is unlikely IMO.
3) I will be trading my SmartBuy GTO in, in September, for a Chevy vehicle, probably Equinox, for the wife and driving her Galant until it's lease is up in May 09. One advantage to SmartBuy: savings on sales tax just like a trade in...When that happens in September, I will pin down whatever Chevy dealer is willing to make that deal and a pricing deal for TWO Camaros in May. I'll obviously be getting one and my 62 year old father, reliving his childhood, told me to make a deal and tell him where to pick it up... Three new vehicles should give me some buying clout. We do have the largest volume Chevy dealer in the country 5 years running, Paddock, here in Buffalo so I'll start there.
Perhaps there are no "processing fees" in your area, here in VA most dealers slap on a $150-$250 processing fee as an add on in the total sale, in effect charging you to process the paperwork they already have to process anyway. And that is not from the '60s/'70s, that is going on today!
Clyde
Clyde
I will not pay MSRP because its based on a value. If MSRP is 32,500 (just an example...) the cars actual worth the next day would probably be $28K if I am lucky.
I'll let someone else pay the 24-hour tax.
I'll let someone else pay the 24-hour tax.
I don't know what rules prevent GM from forcing their dealers to only charge MSRP, but I know that Ferrari will revoke a dealers franchise if they charge a premium, or if they are caught selling to guys looking to flip the car for a profit.
I think that would be price fixing.............although I think the price fixing laws have been relaxed somewhat.
Probably the same.
GOOD LUCK.
Plus dealer holdbacks as mentioned in another response. There is generally also a min commission that a salesman makes and it isn't $25 from those I've spoke with; it's not $1000 either to be fair.
Dealer holdbacks, last time I checked, was 3% for all GM models. Keep in mind they generally consider this "sacred" money. What it really does is allow the "pay $100 under invoice" marketing campaign that they use to draw you in on the high volume movers. IMO, we will not be able to consider that in our negotiations.
But look what you bought "under invoice"...
To make a long story short:
1) I expect the dealers will try 3-5k ABOVE MSRP for the first 2-3 months.
2) I expect that after that short waiting period, not only will you be able to buy below MSRP, but I would bet deals in the invoice+$1000 will be common. I don't expect much below that unless there's end of year fac to dealer incentives on remaining models which is unlikely IMO.
3) I will be trading my SmartBuy GTO in, in September, for a Chevy vehicle, probably Equinox, for the wife and driving her Galant until it's lease is up in May 09. One advantage to SmartBuy: savings on sales tax just like a trade in...When that happens in September, I will pin down whatever Chevy dealer is willing to make that deal and a pricing deal for TWO Camaros in May. I'll obviously be getting one and my 62 year old father, reliving his childhood, told me to make a deal and tell him where to pick it up... Three new vehicles should give me some buying clout. We do have the largest volume Chevy dealer in the country 5 years running, Paddock, here in Buffalo so I'll start there.
GOOD LUCK.
Plus dealer holdbacks as mentioned in another response. There is generally also a min commission that a salesman makes and it isn't $25 from those I've spoke with; it's not $1000 either to be fair.
Dealer holdbacks, last time I checked, was 3% for all GM models. Keep in mind they generally consider this "sacred" money. What it really does is allow the "pay $100 under invoice" marketing campaign that they use to draw you in on the high volume movers. IMO, we will not be able to consider that in our negotiations.
But look what you bought "under invoice"...
To make a long story short:
1) I expect the dealers will try 3-5k ABOVE MSRP for the first 2-3 months.
2) I expect that after that short waiting period, not only will you be able to buy below MSRP, but I would bet deals in the invoice+$1000 will be common. I don't expect much below that unless there's end of year fac to dealer incentives on remaining models which is unlikely IMO.
3) I will be trading my SmartBuy GTO in, in September, for a Chevy vehicle, probably Equinox, for the wife and driving her Galant until it's lease is up in May 09. One advantage to SmartBuy: savings on sales tax just like a trade in...When that happens in September, I will pin down whatever Chevy dealer is willing to make that deal and a pricing deal for TWO Camaros in May. I'll obviously be getting one and my 62 year old father, reliving his childhood, told me to make a deal and tell him where to pick it up... Three new vehicles should give me some buying clout. We do have the largest volume Chevy dealer in the country 5 years running, Paddock, here in Buffalo so I'll start there.
at the dealership i was at the "mini" was $100, and the dealership "pack" was $400 and "detail" took another $50. And the sales guy doesnt get his cut untill AFTER the managers got their cut (sales manager AND "closing manager"), so after all said and done, a full pop MSRP deal was worth $250. FULL POP. and then discount the car even just $800 from MSRP and you got yourself a mini.

At any rate, I can't see paying a premium for a car that they'll be making tens of thousands of for years to come.


