Will removing EGR trip SES??
Will removing EGR trip SES??
Will removing the AIR and EGR using block off plates trip the SES? Let's "pretend" I am working 40 hours a week at one job, going to Univ of Missouri in Rolla for another 15 hours, and firefighting in between. (i.e. don't smoke me for posting a totally stupid question that could prolly be researched in about 45 min...I gotta ton of crap to do and just want a quickie)
Oh yeah, its a OBD1 Z28...
Thanks alot!!
Oh yeah, its a OBD1 Z28...
Thanks alot!!
Re: Will removing EGR trip SES??
Originally Posted by Taintedz28
if you have an OBD-2 car and ahve to apss emissions and you take uot the EGR stuff and have it tuned out of the pcm can you still pass emissions?
Re: Will removing EGR trip SES??
Originally Posted by RE AND CHERYL
That is not correct. The states the test OBD II cars by plugging into the connector will detect the removal of the EGR. The system knows what should be on the car and it will fail or assume the computer is messed up.
Thats not totaly true. I used to do emmisions here in GA and out of 7 items they check you can have two of what they call "not ready" and still pass. If you program out EGR and AIR they will show up as not ready and as long as everything else is running fine then you SHOULD pass. well atleast here in GA. But if you have OBD1 this is all just useless info!
Matt
Re: Will removing EGR trip SES??
Originally Posted by lillbush5555
Thats not totaly true. I used to do emmisions here in GA and out of 7 items they check you can have two of what they call "not ready" and still pass. If you program out EGR and AIR they will show up as not ready and as long as everything else is running fine then you SHOULD pass. well atleast here in GA. But if you have OBD1 this is all just useless info!
Matt
Matt
Re: Will removing EGR trip SES??
On the OBD-I cars, there are two codes related to the EGR system. DTC-27 indicates the vacuum solenoid is not working (or missing). You can eliminate the code but putting a resistor similar in size to the ohms measured across the solenoid, into the harness connector.
DTC-32 indicates the PCM did not see the expected change in the MAP reading when it cycled the EGR valve. The OBD-I diagnostic does not seem to be as critical as the OBD-II diagnostic. Where it probably a 99% chance that the OBD-II PCM will set a code for the lack of EGR flow, I'd estimate that only 20% of the OBD-I PCM's will pick it up.
First approach would be to try removing it and see if you get a code. Simply remove the vacuum line from the solenoid to the EGR valve (capping off the solenoid end) and you will have replicated the effects of removnig the EGR system. See if the code sets/SES light comes on. If it doesn't you cn remove the EGR valve, or block the flow.
If it does set the code/SES, you can have the diagnostic programmed out, just like on the OBD-II cars. Or, you can add a circuit that simulates the effects of EGR flow on the MAP sensor. This involves using the signal for the EGR solenoid to insert a resistor in the MAP circuit when EGR is supposed to be flowing. I don't have the details of the circuit, but a "search" should turn up a link to it.
Of course the question I would ask is why delete the EGR system, when it does not hurt performance in any way, it can provide operating benefits under some conditions, and it really doesn't clutter things up much, since most of its hidden behind the intake manifold?
DTC-32 indicates the PCM did not see the expected change in the MAP reading when it cycled the EGR valve. The OBD-I diagnostic does not seem to be as critical as the OBD-II diagnostic. Where it probably a 99% chance that the OBD-II PCM will set a code for the lack of EGR flow, I'd estimate that only 20% of the OBD-I PCM's will pick it up.
First approach would be to try removing it and see if you get a code. Simply remove the vacuum line from the solenoid to the EGR valve (capping off the solenoid end) and you will have replicated the effects of removnig the EGR system. See if the code sets/SES light comes on. If it doesn't you cn remove the EGR valve, or block the flow.
If it does set the code/SES, you can have the diagnostic programmed out, just like on the OBD-II cars. Or, you can add a circuit that simulates the effects of EGR flow on the MAP sensor. This involves using the signal for the EGR solenoid to insert a resistor in the MAP circuit when EGR is supposed to be flowing. I don't have the details of the circuit, but a "search" should turn up a link to it.
Of course the question I would ask is why delete the EGR system, when it does not hurt performance in any way, it can provide operating benefits under some conditions, and it really doesn't clutter things up much, since most of its hidden behind the intake manifold?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
eanhl2004
General 1967-2002 F-Body Tech
6
Apr 4, 2015 12:01 PM
1994TransAm
Midwest
2
Aug 31, 2002 09:33 PM



