View Poll Results: Is Z284ever Rationally or irrationally Zeta-bashing?
He is legitimately concerned over the apparent course Zeta will take Camaro



39
59.09%
He is irrationally doomsdaying based on what he perceives Zeta to be, which may or may not be true.



27
40.91%
Voters: 66. You may not vote on this poll
Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Originally Posted by Chris 96 WS6
More:
I dont' get how a Camaro that's totally new, based on an excellently engineered chassis, is a few inches shorter than a 4th gen but with a longer, better wheelbase, is a dissappointment?
Because its not pinto sized? Camaro has, since the beginning, been larger than compact vehicle. As long as its in the ballpark I'm cool with it. I'm more concerned with performance, content and overall look than some preconceived notion of the maximum exterior dimesions that would comprise the imaginary perfect Camaro.
Anything under 190 inches in length will be a win in my opinion. Anything under 53 inches in height will be a win in my opinion.
Lets talk about weight. the last of the F-bodies routinely weighed in at 3600 lbs, some more than that. Now everybody has decided somehow that a Camaro over 3400 lbs will be a 100% failure. Guy has already noted that IRS is heavy, and we should expect it to add 200 lbs to any car we get.
If we get a great looking car, with the Camaro badge, a 340-350hp 5.3L and T56, excellent handling with IRS rear, reasonable overall dimensions and it comes in at 3650 lbs that it will somehow be a huge dissappointment?
Maybe it will be for some of you who have set what may be unrealistic expectations, but not for me.
I dont' get how a Camaro that's totally new, based on an excellently engineered chassis, is a few inches shorter than a 4th gen but with a longer, better wheelbase, is a dissappointment?
Because its not pinto sized? Camaro has, since the beginning, been larger than compact vehicle. As long as its in the ballpark I'm cool with it. I'm more concerned with performance, content and overall look than some preconceived notion of the maximum exterior dimesions that would comprise the imaginary perfect Camaro.
Anything under 190 inches in length will be a win in my opinion. Anything under 53 inches in height will be a win in my opinion.
Lets talk about weight. the last of the F-bodies routinely weighed in at 3600 lbs, some more than that. Now everybody has decided somehow that a Camaro over 3400 lbs will be a 100% failure. Guy has already noted that IRS is heavy, and we should expect it to add 200 lbs to any car we get.
If we get a great looking car, with the Camaro badge, a 340-350hp 5.3L and T56, excellent handling with IRS rear, reasonable overall dimensions and it comes in at 3650 lbs that it will somehow be a huge dissappointment?
Maybe it will be for some of you who have set what may be unrealistic expectations, but not for me.
BEAUTIFUL POST!
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Originally Posted by Z284ever
Say you were someone from middle management at GM. Hmmm, oh, I don't know...maybe marketing. And you knew a RWD coupe was coming out. Maybe not ideal for a Camaro certainly.....but it sure would help promote your product if you could use that name. Sure beats Chevelle....or Excalibur, or whatever.
If you really didn't care very much...if you really didn't have much passion for the car......"Camaro" would be an awesome marketing tool for you....even if it really wasn't a Camaro.
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Can we have a poll about PaperTarget's hidden agenda, or not, to bash Camaro? As I recall, Chris and a couple of others out here believe that I'm a Chevy basher just because I find a few faults with them
Take it with a grain of salt Z284ever.
Take it with a grain of salt Z284ever.
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Originally Posted by eagleknight97
How does someone with a middle management position get all the power to decide what a car is called? Especially the right to use the Camaro name? Wouldnt that decision be more up to the likes of Lutz or someone high up like him?
Last edited by Z284ever; Dec 13, 2004 at 04:39 PM.
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
I'm not voting on this one...
Most of us are concerned over the apparent course GM has/will take Camaro... Zeta, Beta, Sigma or whatever. He just feels Zeta is taking it in the wrong direction. I don't know enough about Zeta or the next gen Camaro to have an opinion one way or the other... only what I want in a 5th gen Camaro.
That's a little bit strong of a statement. Maybe he knows more about Zeta that the rest of us. Maybe he has legitimate concerns. Again, I can't make an opinion one way or the other based on something I know very little about. If however, he only knows as much about Zeta as the majority of the people on this board, then I'd say you're dead on.
Until we know more about Zeta, we really can't say much.
He is legitimately concerned over the apparent course Zeta will take Camaro
He is irrationally doomsdaying based on what he perceives Zeta to be, which may or may not be true.
Until we know more about Zeta, we really can't say much.
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Originally Posted by Z284ever
What do you think? Bob Lutz makes all the decisions for 325,000 employees.
HardlyHowever, what I do think is that something with this much potential, and with this much History is not left up to a middle managment person.
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Guys, the poll was tongue-in-cheek. PLease don't take yourselves too seriously, it will make life less fun.
Z, when you say "MUCH bigger", how much is "MUCH bigger"?
How about an example? Bigger than 200" long? On what do you base this assumption?
Z, when you say "MUCH bigger", how much is "MUCH bigger"?
How about an example? Bigger than 200" long? On what do you base this assumption?
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Originally Posted by Chris 96 WS6
How about an example? Bigger than 200" long? On what do you base this assumption?
Last edited by Z284ever; Dec 13, 2004 at 05:33 PM.
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Z, I apologize for my "tactics". Obviously over the top and I can see you're a little hurt. I reckon I would be too, so I'm sorry, and if I were geographically capable I'd buy you a beer. FWIW I still think you have Camaro's best interests in mind, you are a passionate advocate for what you believe in, which is one of the highest compliments I give anyone.
Back to the subject at hand. Clearly you can't say exactly because you have privileged info, but like I said my Trans am is 196 inches long.
Too long? Well, I like the 98+ birds better simply because they chopped 3 inches off the nose.
Full size Toyota Avalon is 191.9" long. So if you are telling me 192 inches long with a 113" wheelbase, that, slightly smaller than the 4th gen with much better proportions. That would be 41.1% overhang-to-length ratio vs. 48.4% for my car. That's a huge improvement. That length would also suggest a Camaro that owes more genetically to the later cars than the 1st gen.
Like I said, if it can be in the ballpark in length, ballpark in weight and look right, I don't have a problem with it. no car they make is going to be perfect, and if they built your ultimate Camaro I'm sure there'd be plenty of people complaining about it too.
Obviously you know more about what is going on internally, and you are concerned enough to be "worried", so its safe to say that it looks like at this point the car is going to go on Zeta.
Now, the name is still far from certain, although it looks like they are leaning to Camaro at this point in time. So, can one assume that if the car gets Camaro enough, the name will stick, and if its looking like its not Camaro enough, it will get some other name?
I don't see GM deciding to call it Chevelle then bringing out a Torana based Camaro in 3 years...too much inner-division overlap, it would be stupid and Z's oft-referenced beancounters would have none of it. Its taken as fact here that there will be a Chevy Zeta coupe. Granted I am totally flying by the seat of my pants here, you guys are the insiders, but to me the current scenario would suggest a Zeta Camaro or No Camaro.
Back to the subject at hand. Clearly you can't say exactly because you have privileged info, but like I said my Trans am is 196 inches long.
Too long? Well, I like the 98+ birds better simply because they chopped 3 inches off the nose.
Full size Toyota Avalon is 191.9" long. So if you are telling me 192 inches long with a 113" wheelbase, that, slightly smaller than the 4th gen with much better proportions. That would be 41.1% overhang-to-length ratio vs. 48.4% for my car. That's a huge improvement. That length would also suggest a Camaro that owes more genetically to the later cars than the 1st gen.
Like I said, if it can be in the ballpark in length, ballpark in weight and look right, I don't have a problem with it. no car they make is going to be perfect, and if they built your ultimate Camaro I'm sure there'd be plenty of people complaining about it too.
Obviously you know more about what is going on internally, and you are concerned enough to be "worried", so its safe to say that it looks like at this point the car is going to go on Zeta.
Now, the name is still far from certain, although it looks like they are leaning to Camaro at this point in time. So, can one assume that if the car gets Camaro enough, the name will stick, and if its looking like its not Camaro enough, it will get some other name?
I don't see GM deciding to call it Chevelle then bringing out a Torana based Camaro in 3 years...too much inner-division overlap, it would be stupid and Z's oft-referenced beancounters would have none of it. Its taken as fact here that there will be a Chevy Zeta coupe. Granted I am totally flying by the seat of my pants here, you guys are the insiders, but to me the current scenario would suggest a Zeta Camaro or No Camaro.
Last edited by Chris 96 WS6; Dec 13, 2004 at 06:07 PM.
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
I really don't think making a post about another Member was quite called for, jokingly or not. Although, both sides seem to have good views. If a Zeta can be made into a lower cowl, smaller than the 4th Gen car, I don't see the problem. If it can't, wait for the Torana and don't bother bringing out a "kinda Camaro" car for us to only dislike and critisize.
Last edited by IZ28; Dec 13, 2004 at 09:33 PM.
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Originally Posted by Chris 96 WS6
Z, I apologize for my "tactics". Obviously over the top and I can see you're a little hurt. I reckon I would be too, so I'm sorry, and if I were geographically capable I'd buy you a beer.
It's not about me anyway, it's about Camaro....that's why I'm here in the first place.
BTW, my current drink of choice is a Kettle One martini, straight up with a blue cheese olive.
Darth, on the other hand, is on my sh!tlist!
Last edited by Z284ever; Dec 13, 2004 at 08:58 PM.
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Originally Posted by Z284ever
Darth, on the other hand, is on my sh!tlist!


I've been here for sometime, no??

Actually, you are one of my favorite people to disagree with... you don't fly off the handle when your views are debated.
Re: Z284ever and Zeta-bashing Poll
Originally Posted by Chris 96 WS6
I don't see GM deciding to call it Chevelle then bringing out a Torana based Camaro in 3 years...too much inner-division overlap, it would be stupid and Z's oft-referenced beancounters would have none of it. Its taken as fact here that there will be a Chevy Zeta coupe. Granted I am totally flying by the seat of my pants here, you guys are the insiders, but to me the current scenario would suggest a Zeta Camaro or No Camaro.
The Torana's architecture has alot of support at GM. And I mean support all the way to the top. And it hasn't escaped some, that this could form the basis of a great Chevy "ponycar". Forged aluminum, double wishbone control arms all around, coil over shocks/springs, rigid hydroformed rails, tidy exterior dimensions combined with roomy interior, top drawer stuff that can be manufactured cost effectively. Basing a Camaro off of this, makes me drool!
The problem right now is cash. GM doesn't have any. But as soon as they get some things out of the way....they will.
If we go off the deleted "list", we can expect the Chevy Zeta coupe in CY2008. 4 years from now. 4 years is a long time. What a pity it would be, if during that time, "Beta" were approved (and if alot of very important people get their way, it will).....but the Camaro name had gone to a large sedan based product.
Last edited by Z284ever; Dec 14, 2004 at 12:28 AM.

