Is upgrading from shorties to Long tubes worth the $$ ?
#47
I have not heard one person on this board that told me they didn't like the way my exhaust sounds with heads/cam/LTs/!cat/ and Borla. Maybe I installed the right combination of quality performance parts.
#48
Originally posted by AsianSensation
I have not heard one person on this board that told me they didn't like the way my exhaust sounds with heads/cam/LTs/!cat/ and Borla. Maybe I installed the right combination of quality performance parts.
I have not heard one person on this board that told me they didn't like the way my exhaust sounds with heads/cam/LTs/!cat/ and Borla. Maybe I installed the right combination of quality performance parts.
so i changed it
jesse
#50
Originally posted by Shon Herron
Anyone want to donate a set of shorties and some dyno money? I can make 3 pulls one day, then 3 pulls the next day. Just let me know who is interested and I can provide you accounts for deposits and a shipping address.
Anyone want to donate a set of shorties and some dyno money? I can make 3 pulls one day, then 3 pulls the next day. Just let me know who is interested and I can provide you accounts for deposits and a shipping address.
I WOULD have gave you my AS&M's, but I just don't think it's possible to R&I headers that fast. honest I would have...
#51
You can say what you want about the shorties vs the LTs. I speak from experience with my car. I have a 383 Stroker, stage 3 CNC/P&P heads, cc305 cam. I had the Edelbrock shorties on my car and they seemed to work OK other than they got really hot because they were uncoated. I had my car dyno tuned with the shorties on. I was getting everything I could out of them. I had put the heads on after I had dyno tuned. These heads are rated for about 50hp increase. I sure couldn't feel that much of a performance increase. There should be a SOTP feeling with 50 HP. I just didn't notice a big difference. Don't get me wrong there was a difference but not what I was expecting.
Now, when I switched my headers to the Hooker LTs my car awoke a beast within. This car came to life like nothing that I could have imagined with just swapping the headers. I had to have my car retuned just so that it would run correctly. The motor was starving for more air and couldn't get it. I was not taking full advantage of the heads with those shorties on there. I thought I had a lot of torque with the stroker before the LTs and did. But OMG what a difference there was after the LTs.
Now, I might be an exception to the rule because of the heads and the stroker with more cubes. But I am telling you that I got my moneys worth and then some by putting those LTs on. I love the power increase that I have received from putting mine on. The SOTP feeling was just awesome compared to the shorties. Not to mention how incredible the car sounds now.
I have had both so you can say what you like, but I know what the difference was with my car. Unless you have had both on your car you can not judge the differences fairly. You can quote whatever articles you would like, each car is different and will get different gains based on the person's setup. In my situation the changes were extremely different in regards to performance.
Now, when I switched my headers to the Hooker LTs my car awoke a beast within. This car came to life like nothing that I could have imagined with just swapping the headers. I had to have my car retuned just so that it would run correctly. The motor was starving for more air and couldn't get it. I was not taking full advantage of the heads with those shorties on there. I thought I had a lot of torque with the stroker before the LTs and did. But OMG what a difference there was after the LTs.
Now, I might be an exception to the rule because of the heads and the stroker with more cubes. But I am telling you that I got my moneys worth and then some by putting those LTs on. I love the power increase that I have received from putting mine on. The SOTP feeling was just awesome compared to the shorties. Not to mention how incredible the car sounds now.
I have had both so you can say what you like, but I know what the difference was with my car. Unless you have had both on your car you can not judge the differences fairly. You can quote whatever articles you would like, each car is different and will get different gains based on the person's setup. In my situation the changes were extremely different in regards to performance.
#53
Originally posted by Zepp
I have had both so you can say what you like, but I know what the difference was with my car. Unless you have had both on your car you can not judge the differences fairly. You can quote whatever articles you would like, each car is different and will get different gains based on the person's setup. In my situation the changes were extremely different in regards to performance.
I have had both so you can say what you like, but I know what the difference was with my car. Unless you have had both on your car you can not judge the differences fairly. You can quote whatever articles you would like, each car is different and will get different gains based on the person's setup. In my situation the changes were extremely different in regards to performance.
You acknowledge that your setup is unique(far from stock) and that your heads and stroker might have something to do with your individual results. Yet you make generalizations strongly advocating longtubes. You also take a negative stance to those of us who have referenced literature and have not personally used both setups on their cars.
IMO your post should be about primary tube size, not length. If you read the vizard article you will find that a 1 3/4" primary would be recommended for your application and that the article is not contradicting your results at all, but rather correctly predicted that your car would gain from the larger 1 3/4" primaries of the long tubes you installed.
This thread has become a somewhat generalized discussion branching from the inital question. That is why my previous post covered both stock and modified cars backed up with some references of actual tests and not just gut feelings about flow or SOTP.
I did infact mention at the bottom of my first post that 93 formy may see gains. Information was provided for him to draw his own conclusions. I personally dread the thought of installing headers on an LT1 so if it where my car i'm not sure that I'd pursue that mod, it just depends what your priorities and goals are.
Your first hand experience/input IS appreciated.
-brent
#55
Originally posted by Zepp
You can say what you want about the shorties vs the LTs. I speak from experience with my car. I have a 383 Stroker, stage 3 CNC/P&P heads, cc305 cam. I had the Edelbrock shorties on my car and they seemed to work OK other than they got really hot because they were uncoated. I had my car dyno tuned with the shorties on. I was getting everything I could out of them. I had put the heads on after I had dyno tuned. These heads are rated for about 50hp increase. I sure couldn't feel that much of a performance increase. There should be a SOTP feeling with 50 HP. I just didn't notice a big difference. Don't get me wrong there was a difference but not what I was expecting.
Now, when I switched my headers to the Hooker LTs my car awoke a beast within. This car came to life like nothing that I could have imagined with just swapping the headers. I had to have my car retuned just so that it would run correctly. The motor was starving for more air and couldn't get it. I was not taking full advantage of the heads with those shorties on there. I thought I had a lot of torque with the stroker before the LTs and did. But OMG what a difference there was after the LTs.
Now, I might be an exception to the rule because of the heads and the stroker with more cubes. But I am telling you that I got my moneys worth and then some by putting those LTs on. I love the power increase that I have received from putting mine on. The SOTP feeling was just awesome compared to the shorties. Not to mention how incredible the car sounds now.
I have had both so you can say what you like, but I know what the difference was with my car. Unless you have had both on your car you can not judge the differences fairly. You can quote whatever articles you would like, each car is different and will get different gains based on the person's setup. In my situation the changes were extremely different in regards to performance.
You can say what you want about the shorties vs the LTs. I speak from experience with my car. I have a 383 Stroker, stage 3 CNC/P&P heads, cc305 cam. I had the Edelbrock shorties on my car and they seemed to work OK other than they got really hot because they were uncoated. I had my car dyno tuned with the shorties on. I was getting everything I could out of them. I had put the heads on after I had dyno tuned. These heads are rated for about 50hp increase. I sure couldn't feel that much of a performance increase. There should be a SOTP feeling with 50 HP. I just didn't notice a big difference. Don't get me wrong there was a difference but not what I was expecting.
Now, when I switched my headers to the Hooker LTs my car awoke a beast within. This car came to life like nothing that I could have imagined with just swapping the headers. I had to have my car retuned just so that it would run correctly. The motor was starving for more air and couldn't get it. I was not taking full advantage of the heads with those shorties on there. I thought I had a lot of torque with the stroker before the LTs and did. But OMG what a difference there was after the LTs.
Now, I might be an exception to the rule because of the heads and the stroker with more cubes. But I am telling you that I got my moneys worth and then some by putting those LTs on. I love the power increase that I have received from putting mine on. The SOTP feeling was just awesome compared to the shorties. Not to mention how incredible the car sounds now.
I have had both so you can say what you like, but I know what the difference was with my car. Unless you have had both on your car you can not judge the differences fairly. You can quote whatever articles you would like, each car is different and will get different gains based on the person's setup. In my situation the changes were extremely different in regards to performance.
Funny thing...I don't see any quarter mile times listed in your posts, or your sig.??? Surely your 383, LT equipped car must be quicker than my stock bottom end 350, mid length header eqipped car, right?
Frank
Last edited by 12SCNDZ; 01-24-2004 at 10:23 AM.
#56
Originally posted by juiced_lt1
***k the longtubes, worth maybe 5-8hp over shorties and cost quite a bit. Get a cutout after the ypipe for $35 for when you go to the track.
***k the longtubes, worth maybe 5-8hp over shorties and cost quite a bit. Get a cutout after the ypipe for $35 for when you go to the track.
As i've said time and time again, I swapped from shorties to LTs and will never go back!
#57
Well guys, I'd just like to thank all those who took the time to respond to my post. Though not much was resolved as far as whether or not the LT's are worth the extra money, I've decided to go ahaed with the LT's. The general opinion on this forum and others that I have posted on, is that while mid-lengths would probably give you more on the top end, LT's would increase the torque in the low-mid range. The more I thought about it, the more sense it made for me to go with the LT's. I spend 99% of the time driving around between 2 and 3500rpm so it just makes sense to go with a set of headers that make power in that rpm range. I just ordered a set of JetHot's from Fbody Central (anyone have any experience with them?) last night so I should get them, within a week or so. Since I never did buy my Ededlbrocks to begin with, these will technically be the first pair of headers I've bought for my car. I'll post some pics when they arrive.
Thanks again to all those who responded. Man, I hope all that money was worth it and I don't regret it.....
Thanks again to all those who responded. Man, I hope all that money was worth it and I don't regret it.....
#58
Originally posted by 12SCNDZ
Here's a dyno chart reprinted directly out of Car Craft
http://www.geocities.com/max_wylde/dyno.html
Frank
Here's a dyno chart reprinted directly out of Car Craft
http://www.geocities.com/max_wylde/dyno.html
Frank
#59
Originally posted by EbeZ28
I have pondered for some time about what kind of headers to get. Based on the dyno information in the link above as well as clearance/install issues, I am sold on shorties/mids. Very enlightening thread
I have pondered for some time about what kind of headers to get. Based on the dyno information in the link above as well as clearance/install issues, I am sold on shorties/mids. Very enlightening thread