Disappointment with the Concept
Disappointment with the Concept
I don’t want to be a wet blanket here but I thought I’d offer an observation for what it’s worth.
I was (and still am) very pleased to see that there is a Camaro concept…nothing would make me happier to see the car brought back. That said, after the initial excitement at the simple fact that there IS a concept, I’ve grown to like the design less and less.
It’s not that I think the design isn’t a good-looking car…I think it is…the source of my dissatisfaction is the lack of originality in the design…disappointment that GM’s designers couldn’t have broken some new ground rather than jumping on the “retro” bandwagon.
Designing a car today that looks so much like the car produced almost 40 years ago just seems like the wrong way to go…I have a feeling that after the initial excitement and acceptance, the manufacturers are going to find that the public will quickly grow tired of the “retro” look.
I don’t dislike the concept…but there is a lot more to the chemistry of “Camaro” than the body lines. I also recognize that much of the car's potential success will depend on many factors, not just the body...I just wish the designers had come up with something unique and fresh while unmistakably a Camaro.
I know that’s a lot to ask for but I think it’s what is needed if the car is going to come back and, more importantly, survive long-term.
I was (and still am) very pleased to see that there is a Camaro concept…nothing would make me happier to see the car brought back. That said, after the initial excitement at the simple fact that there IS a concept, I’ve grown to like the design less and less.
It’s not that I think the design isn’t a good-looking car…I think it is…the source of my dissatisfaction is the lack of originality in the design…disappointment that GM’s designers couldn’t have broken some new ground rather than jumping on the “retro” bandwagon.
Designing a car today that looks so much like the car produced almost 40 years ago just seems like the wrong way to go…I have a feeling that after the initial excitement and acceptance, the manufacturers are going to find that the public will quickly grow tired of the “retro” look.
I don’t dislike the concept…but there is a lot more to the chemistry of “Camaro” than the body lines. I also recognize that much of the car's potential success will depend on many factors, not just the body...I just wish the designers had come up with something unique and fresh while unmistakably a Camaro.
I know that’s a lot to ask for but I think it’s what is needed if the car is going to come back and, more importantly, survive long-term.
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
Are you on the same planet as the rest of us?
Say it with us now.... "IT AIN'T RETRO!"
And I think most of the Camaro community would disagree with you.
You'll be seeing a lot of the rear end of that Camaro too from the seat of your Nissan Z. So you'd better get to like it
.
Say it with us now.... "IT AIN'T RETRO!"
And I think most of the Camaro community would disagree with you.
You'll be seeing a lot of the rear end of that Camaro too from the seat of your Nissan Z. So you'd better get to like it
.
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
Originally Posted by Robert_Nashville
...I just wish the designers had come up with something unique and fresh while unmistakably a Camaro...
the boxy look to it is more 3rd gen than anything i think
i think it will look much better in person as everyone says though, going to stop now before i spill off a bunch of stuff that has already been said
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
I don't think the designers could have possibly done a better job of coming up with something "unique and fresh yet unmistakably Camaro". The concept is everything a Camaro should be. You want to talk about lack of originality? Look at the 05 Mustang and the new Challenger.
The Camaro concept looks futuristic yet muscular, mean and aggressive. It is what the Camaro should be.
The Camaro concept looks futuristic yet muscular, mean and aggressive. It is what the Camaro should be.
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
I'm with ya, I was also disappointed that it came out retro (and for the love of god, those of you saying it's not retro please get your eyes checked).
But I find myself moving in the opposite direction to you: as time has moved on, I find myself liking it more instead of less. I guess that's the way with most things, that once you become accustomed to something you can begin to overlook its shortcomings.
I still won't be buying one, and I still hate that GM didn't have the *****/talent to take a step forward instead of backward, but I can at least appreciate it as a good looking car now.
But I find myself moving in the opposite direction to you: as time has moved on, I find myself liking it more instead of less. I guess that's the way with most things, that once you become accustomed to something you can begin to overlook its shortcomings.
I still won't be buying one, and I still hate that GM didn't have the *****/talent to take a step forward instead of backward, but I can at least appreciate it as a good looking car now.
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
Originally Posted by 3_z28camaro
Not to be mean or anything but
Nashville why are you here if you do not even own a Camaro, but import Nissan crap boxes? The Camaro is not retro it has heritage, but it is not a carbon copy with a fancy paint job and bigger wheels like the Challenger. Some idiots over on camaros.net do not like it because it is not retro enough, morons.
Go see it in person, if you can, I have heard it makes all the difference.
Nashville why are you here if you do not even own a Camaro, but import Nissan crap boxes? The Camaro is not retro it has heritage, but it is not a carbon copy with a fancy paint job and bigger wheels like the Challenger. Some idiots over on camaros.net do not like it because it is not retro enough, morons.
Go see it in person, if you can, I have heard it makes all the difference.
But anyways... the car is too retro for me as well. Oh well, GM cant please everybody with one design. It looks too much like a futuristic '69 Camaro to me inside and out. My dad on the other hand said the concept wasnt "retro" enough. Its fitting that I dont like the new retro 'Stang either, which he loves.
It sucks for me cause I was really wanting to get this car when it came out... but now I'll probably be buying a used Vette or an import sports car of some sort.
Hopefully the car does good for GM though...
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
Originally Posted by 3_z28camaro
Not to be mean or anything but
Nashville why are you here if you do not even own a Camaro, but import Nissan crap boxes? The Camaro is not retro it has heritage, but it is not a carbon copy with a fancy paint job and bigger wheels like the Challenger. Some idiots over on camaros.net do not like it because it is not retro enough, morons.
Go see it in person, if you can, I have heard it makes all the difference.
Nashville why are you here if you do not even own a Camaro, but import Nissan crap boxes? The Camaro is not retro it has heritage, but it is not a carbon copy with a fancy paint job and bigger wheels like the Challenger. Some idiots over on camaros.net do not like it because it is not retro enough, morons.
Go see it in person, if you can, I have heard it makes all the difference.
Shut up.....
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
Would all those that say, "its too retro" AND have actually seen it in person, please raise their hands....
... anyone, anyone....
[crickets chirping = on]....
.... [crickets chirping = off]
... anyone, anyone....
[crickets chirping = on]....
.... [crickets chirping = off]
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
Originally Posted by jg95z28
Would all those that say, "its too retro" AND have actually seen it in person, please raise their hands....
... anyone, anyone....
[crickets chirping = on]....
.... [crickets chirping = off]

... anyone, anyone....
[crickets chirping = on]....
.... [crickets chirping = off]

There are things I do like about the concept... the size and proportions in my opinion are dead on. The chassis looks to be really nice... just not for me.
I dont see why people seem to be offended when someone says they're not taken with the concept. You cant please everyone.
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
Originally Posted by Z28Marcus
Are you on the same planet as the rest of us?
Say it with us now.... "IT AIN'T RETRO!"
And I think most of the Camaro community would disagree with you.
You'll be seeing a lot of the rear end of that Camaro too from the seat of your Nissan Z. So you'd better get to like it
.
Say it with us now.... "IT AIN'T RETRO!"
And I think most of the Camaro community would disagree with you.
You'll be seeing a lot of the rear end of that Camaro too from the seat of your Nissan Z. So you'd better get to like it
.
Last edited by Robert_Nashville; Jan 30, 2006 at 05:54 PM.
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
Originally Posted by Steve0
99% of people who see the concept worldwide will only be able to do so through pictures. I really don't think seeing it in person is going to change my opinion that much. I dont have the resources to travel to one of the auto shows the car will be appearing at, so it looks like I wont be able to see one in person until it hits dealer lots. Until then I have a few videos, pictures and magazine articles. Maybe the design will grow on me with time, but until then...
There are things I do like about the concept... the size and proportions in my opinion are dead on. The chassis looks to be really nice... just not for me.
I dont see why people seem to be offended when someone says they're not taken with the concept. You cant please everyone.
There are things I do like about the concept... the size and proportions in my opinion are dead on. The chassis looks to be really nice... just not for me.
I dont see why people seem to be offended when someone says they're not taken with the concept. You cant please everyone.
That's not to say everyone loves it. However few say "its too retro" after seeing it.
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
I think its very modern looking. It has an overall shape and some style that the the origionals had. But the look and the style is very modern. And it looked great in LA.
Re: Disappointment with the Concept
Originally Posted by 3_z28camaro
Not to be mean or anything but
Nashville why are you here if you do not even own a Camaro, but import Nissan crap boxes? The Camaro is not retro it has heritage, but it is not a carbon copy with a fancy paint job and bigger wheels like the Challenger. Some idiots over on camaros.net do not like it because it is not retro enough, morons.
Go see it in person, if you can, I have heard it makes all the difference.
Nashville why are you here if you do not even own a Camaro, but import Nissan crap boxes? The Camaro is not retro it has heritage, but it is not a carbon copy with a fancy paint job and bigger wheels like the Challenger. Some idiots over on camaros.net do not like it because it is not retro enough, morons.
Go see it in person, if you can, I have heard it makes all the difference.
Perhaps I'm here because I happen to be an enthusiast regardless of the nameplate.
Maybe I’m here because I like Firebird and Camaro “people”; well, most of them anyway.
Maybe I’m here because I’ve owned a few ('73, '76, '79’ and '00) - so maybe I have something to say about Firebird/Camaro “heritage”.
Maybe I just like to talk with other enthusiasts even when they don’t agree with me.


