Okay so I lied...when I was applying Armor All to my dash I cracked a tiny triangle off the corner of that HUGE plastic piece next to the windshield. It was my fault, not the Armor All's. I dunno exactly why I'm not more pissed at myself right now....but I guess it's because I SHOULD be able to still glue back that tiny triangle without it looking TOO bad.

 

Good luck with the repair...

If you have a hard time, you'll probably be able to find a good used replacement part at a junk yard or even on eBay...