correct way to correct knock
#1
correct way to correct knock
What is the best way to correct know. If it says
RPMs: 3600
Spark Adv.: 28
Spark Ret.: 11
MAP: 75 KPa
Do i adjust the spark advance ? Would i adjust -11? I just started to lower the advance by 1 to see what happens, but my clutch went out so while i wait to get time in the garage, i wanted to ask this question.
Plus how much should i worry about .5, .8 degrees of retard.
RPMs: 3600
Spark Adv.: 28
Spark Ret.: 11
MAP: 75 KPa
Do i adjust the spark advance ? Would i adjust -11? I just started to lower the advance by 1 to see what happens, but my clutch went out so while i wait to get time in the garage, i wanted to ask this question.
Plus how much should i worry about .5, .8 degrees of retard.
#2
Still can't get that thing running well huh?
I'd love to see that Ed Wright file compared to the one I sent you.
Take timing out at that map and rpm if the computer is retarding timing.
Was this WOT?
BTW, you should tune for no knock.
I'd love to see that Ed Wright file compared to the one I sent you.
Take timing out at that map and rpm if the computer is retarding timing.
Was this WOT?
BTW, you should tune for no knock.
#3
Dan, i was worried, maybe pissed you off or something since i never got a respnce to the last email. Hope things are going good for you. The car runs like a champ now. There are only two maybe three points were i'm getting retard. I was curious what to do since the advance was at 28 and it said 11 degrees of retard, so bringing the advance down to 17 didn't sound right. I have one point that hits around 5 degrees retard and one that is around 10 degrees and a couple little ones that spike no further then .5-.9 degrees retard.
I do beleive that the retard was at WOT.
I would love to see the Ed Wright file myself just to see what $300 got me.
Like i said putting the retard that low didn't sound right.
I do beleive that the retard was at WOT.
I would love to see the Ed Wright file myself just to see what $300 got me.
Like i said putting the retard that low didn't sound right.
#4
MAP usually hits 100 pretty quick at WOT so you weren't quite there but pretty close.
I would pull out 2 degree's of timing in the area's where you're getting KR then retest. The PCM is very conservative so it pulls out ALOT of timing when it detects KR.
You could also be runnnig lean at those points which could induce knock as well. But you really have no way of knowing if you are or arent without a wideband O2 sensor.
I would pull out 2 degree's of timing in the area's where you're getting KR then retest. The PCM is very conservative so it pulls out ALOT of timing when it detects KR.
You could also be runnnig lean at those points which could induce knock as well. But you really have no way of knowing if you are or arent without a wideband O2 sensor.
#5
The first thing you need to do is determine if your knock is real. Chances are it's not. You can do this by putting some 100 octane gas in (do not use octane boosters as they are falsely advertised. If you still get the knock it's false.
You also didn't mention if you were wot when you reported your data. 75 kpa is a good load but can be hit without going wot.
My car was getting buttloads of knock at part throttle - I assumed it was false and zeroed out all the spark retard tables. Car ran noticeably better, with no pinging or knocking.
Even with an LT4 KM, roller rockers, headers, aftermarket plug wires, and lugging a cammed car all contribute to false knock.
Joe
You also didn't mention if you were wot when you reported your data. 75 kpa is a good load but can be hit without going wot.
My car was getting buttloads of knock at part throttle - I assumed it was false and zeroed out all the spark retard tables. Car ran noticeably better, with no pinging or knocking.
Even with an LT4 KM, roller rockers, headers, aftermarket plug wires, and lugging a cammed car all contribute to false knock.
Joe
#6
Re: correct way to correct knock
Originally posted by 1BadBrd
What is the best way to correct know. If it says
RPMs: 3600
Spark Adv.: 28
Spark Ret.: 11
MAP: 75 KPa
Do i adjust the spark advance ? Would i adjust -11? I just started to lower the advance by 1 to see what happens, but my clutch went out so while i wait to get time in the garage, i wanted to ask this question.
Plus how much should i worry about .5, .8 degrees of retard.
What is the best way to correct know. If it says
RPMs: 3600
Spark Adv.: 28
Spark Ret.: 11
MAP: 75 KPa
Do i adjust the spark advance ? Would i adjust -11? I just started to lower the advance by 1 to see what happens, but my clutch went out so while i wait to get time in the garage, i wanted to ask this question.
Plus how much should i worry about .5, .8 degrees of retard.
As noted in the posts above, before you start altering the timing, find out if the knock is real or false. If its real, correct the source of the problem, which may be excessive timing, or might be poor quality fuel, excessive coolant temp, excessive inlet air temp, carbon buildup, etc.
If you were just to pull 11deg timing out of the program, you would just reduce performance all the time to the levels the "retard" is causing you now.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post